Dior's 'all hand-drawn' holiday film turned out to use automated interpolation. With ASCI's AI ad rules arriving in late December, Indian brands should treat 'no AI' as a claim that needs proof.
01Dior’s holiday film ‘Christian Dior’s Night in Color’, released on 4 November 2026, was promoted as all hand-drawn but drew AI accusations over visual glitches.
02Director Sylvain Chomet told Variety that an automated interpolation system was used for a very small part of the Dior film.
03Coca-Cola is running an AI-made ‘Holidays Are Coming’ holiday ad for a third year despite repeated backlash.
04ASCI’s guidelines on synthetically generated content in ads, issued on 29 September 2026, take effect three months after publication and bar misleading claims even when labelled.
Dior called its holiday film hand-drawn. Within a day, viewers were counting fingers. The lesson from the Dior AI ad row isn’t “never use AI”. It’s this: a “no AI” or “handmade” claim is now an ad claim like any other, and you need proof before you make it.
That matters in India sooner than you think. ASCI’s new rules on synthetically generated content in ads kick in around 29 December 2026, and they treat misleading claims as off-limits whether or not you add a label.
Dior released “Christian Dior’s Night in Color”, an animated short directed by French animator Sylvain Chomet, on 4 November 2026. Creative director Jonathan Anderson described it as “all hand-drawn using techniques that go back to the 1940s”. Critics on X and Threads then flagged warped lettering, a lazy eye and a six-fingered hand, and accused the house of using AI.
The cast list is starry: Robert Pattinson, Rihanna, Josh O’Connor, Greta Lee and LaKeith Stanfield. The story follows Christian Dior designing for his friend Marlene Dietrich. None of that helped once the finger-counting began.
Partly, by its director’s own account. Chomet told Variety on 7 November that an automated interpolation system handled “a very small part of the process”, while insisting the film is traditional 2D animation. Interpolation generates in-between frames. So the film wasn’t AI-generated, but “all hand-drawn” wasn’t the whole picture either.
Chomet also defended the anatomy. He said a hand fanned out in motion can briefly show six or seven fingers, and that a nose can shift shape across five frames of a head turn. Animators will recognise that as an old trick. The internet heard it as a confession.
Inc. reported on 9 November that Dior had not responded to its request for comment. Everything on record so far comes from Chomet and Anderson.
The audience didn’t punish the tool. It punished the gap between the claim and the frame.
Because AI fatigue is now a creative brief. Adweek’s Robert Klara noted on 11 November that this season’s holiday work keeps showing off human craft without ever naming AI. Etsy’s “Ornaments” spot puts handmade decorations on a tree. Inc. points to Prada’s hand-drawn film and Levi’s stop-motion yeti, Gus.
Then there’s Coca-Cola, running AI-made “Holidays Are Coming” trucks for a third straight year. Writing in The Drum on 9 November, Andrew Tindall said his own 300-person test scored the 2026 spot 5.7 stars, close to the 5.9 he cites from System1 for the two earlier versions. Islam ElDessouky, Coca-Cola’s global VP for creative strategy and content, told Marketing Dive in 2025 that despite the noise, “we’re going to keep going at it”.
Two big brands, opposite bets. Coke said “AI” out loud and took the heat on taste. Dior said “hand-drawn” and took the heat on honesty. The second one hurts more.
Probably not, and that’s the twist. ASCI’s guidelines, issued on 29 September 2026, exempt routine editing and obvious fantastical or stylised elements. A cartoon couturier misleads no one about a product. The risk sits elsewhere: ASCI bars misleading claims outright, so an untrue “all hand-drawn” line is the exposure, not the missing label.
ASCI’s rules start three months from publication. Mandatory labels cover synthetic influencers, cloned voices or likenesses used with consent, fabricated events that shape how buyers understand a product, and demos of products that don’t exist yet. Suggested labels include “Video created using AI” and “Video enhanced using AI”. If a complaint is upheld, the advertiser has ten business days to withdraw or modify the ad.
ASCI CEO and Secretary General Manisha Kapoor put it plainly: “our approach must evolve with it”. She has also said a label alone won’t rescue a misleading ad. Separately, MeitY’s IT Amendment Rules, in force since 20 February 2026, make large platforms label realistic synthetic media that looks like real people or events. Stylised animation largely sits outside that definition.
Our reading, not legal advice. We placed each campaign in ASCI’s three buckets as if it ran in India after the rules take effect.
| Campaign | AI use (as reported) | ASCI bucket, our reading | Real risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dior, Night in Color | Interpolation for a small part | No label needed (stylised) | The “all hand-drawn” claim |
| Coca-Cola, Holidays Are Coming | AI-generated visuals | No label needed if fantastical; check any realistic people | Taste backlash, not compliance |
| A D2C serum ad with AI “before/after” skin | Synthetic product results | Prohibited, label or not | Complaint and takedown |
| A jewellery brand’s AI brand ambassador | Synthetic influencer | Mandatory label | Missing label |
The last two rows are hypotheticals we built to show the line. They’re where Indian beauty, jewellery and fintech brands are most exposed this wedding season.
Watch this: “100% handmade”, “shot on camera, no CGI” and “real customers” are now claims a rival can complain about. Keep the proof before the post goes live.
Only if you can document every stage. Most production pipelines now touch AI somewhere: rotoscoping, upscaling, noise cleanup, frame interpolation, even subtitles. A blanket “no AI” line is one vendor’s software choice away from being false. Claim the craft you can prove, specifically.
The counterpoint deserves a hearing. Coke’s numbers suggest the backlash crowd is loud and small, and Dior’s film still got global coverage. Some marketers will argue any row is free reach. Our view: that works once for a luxury house with decades of goodwill. A ₹50 crore D2C label caught lying about craft gets the screenshots, not the halo.
Use AI where it helps and say so when the rules require it. Never sell “handmade” or “no AI” as a badge unless your edit log backs every frame. The Dior row shows the punishment comes for the overclaim, not the tool. If you can’t prove it, say what you did by hand instead.
If you’re tightening AI disclosure across channels, our pieces on what AI text watermarks really detect and YouTube’s original content rule for Shorts cover the platform side. For craft-led work that won on results, see the Maggi Grand Effie case study and Sting’s F1 sound campaign.
Director Sylvain Chomet told Variety that an automated interpolation system was used for a very small part of the process. He maintains the film is traditional 2D animation. Dior itself has not issued a detailed on-record response.
The film is ‘Christian Dior’s Night in Color’, an animated short directed by Sylvain Chomet. It debuted on 4 November 2026 and centres on Christian Dior’s friendship with Marlene Dietrich.
ASCI issued its guidelines on synthetically generated content in advertising on 29 September 2026. They take effect three months from publication, which by PingTalks’ count is around 29 December 2026.
Labels are mandatory for synthetic influencers, consented replicas of a real person’s voice or likeness, fabricated events that shape product understanding and demos of products that do not yet exist. Routine edits, obvious fantasy elements, ad copy and accessibility uses are exempt.
No. ASCI prohibits misleading claims, fabricated testimonials and misleading synthetic product results whether or not the ad carries an AI label. ASCI CEO Manisha Kapoor has said responsibility stays with the advertiser.
Digital Evangelist and Entrepreneur at Clickseek Digital. A results-oriented marketing leader with an 18+ year track record driving transformative growth for diverse global businesses. Expert in performance marketing, demand generation, customer acquisition, strategic partnerships, and market expansion within B2B SaaS, Consumer-Tech, Fintech, Travel/Hospitality, and CRM/ITES Solutions sectors. IIM alumnus with a strong analytical background and a string of accolades, including "Top 50 Most Influential E-Commerce Professional of India" and "Top 100 Digital Marketer of India."
What changed in marketing and AI, why it matters and exactly what to do. In your inbox at 11:00 IST.
